Natual Gas and Oil Report
Energies
Decline as Natural Gas Turns a “ Cold Shoulder” in
the Face of a Record Storage Draw Encouraging Technical Sellers.
Technical Outlook: last week we stated in our
report that we expect a rapid test of minor resistance at $15.75-15.80,
and we also echoed this projection in an interview with the Dow
Jones newswires on the same date of December the eighth. We also
forecasted strong support buying on pullbacks first at $14 .75
, and then $14 .20 , which was confirmed as the low on Friday.
Our upside target was pinpointed and confirmed exactly between
our bracket with the intra-day high posted at $15 .78 on this past
Tuesday , December the 13th , and right within the three session
time cycle predicted following our report on last Thursday , December
the eighth. Looking ahead, the market has since then staged a full
retreat by Bull forces, putting the market into a negative posture
indicative of a corrective phase. Technical indicators suggest
further weakness as the market subsides from a sharp short-term
peak , resulting in an overbought condition. We see a continued
short-term negative signal emanating from the stochastics, relative
strength, momentum, and the MACD which declares a wide negative
divergence along with a parabolic reading that is just about to
turn negative. From this technical posture , we anticipate a test
soon of key pivot support at $13 .50 with a close below this possibly
bringing a rapid challenge to intermediate support at $13 .02 and
then more critically at $12.60-12.74 before Bull forces reemerge
to stem the decline. We expect rebound attempts to be contained
by the $14.20 level until the corrective phase is completed. Once
this is accomplished, look for a close back above $14 .70 to signal
a continuation of the up trend, and an eventual challenge to the
highs. However , we see the potential for a rapid diminishing of
selling strength once prices get below $13.50 making the market
vulnerable to a sharp bullish reversal to emerge from a strong
undertone of value buying scaled-down from $13.10 to $12 .50.
Fundamental Supply Update
Today the EIA
reported a surprising record withdrawal from storage of 202bcfs,
that was well above both Bloomberg and Dow Jones estimates that
were in the lower 170s as well as comfortably above our company
call for a reduction of 162-167 bcfs. However , the expected
bullish reaction, which initially created a strong buying impulse
, taking the market out of the early negative sub-$14 .20 level
into a sharp vertical advance to the intra-day peak of $14.92,
only lasted minutes as these gains quickly evaporated into profit-taking
and new short-sellers that soon pushed prices into new negative
territory and settling the market , sharply lower to settle below
key support at $13 .78. Storage now stands at 2964 bcfs , which
is 195 bcfs less than last year, and yet still 107 bcfs above
the five-year average of 2857 bcfs. Normally under such a negative
reaction immediately following such a bullish news event, one
could draw a conclusion that a deeper weakness exists in the
core of the market , indicating a potential end to the Bull trend,
however , we feel this would be both a premature , as well as
an unwise assumption. While it is clear the market is obviously
attempting to put in a short-term top, we feel it is likely to
be just that, a peak in pricing for the month of December only,
as we stated in a news interview with DTN today. We also stated
in that same interview that today’s record withdrawal
for a week in December will likely come back to haunt this market
as it is quite telling and it is the first indication of the true
impact of the production lost to hurricanes Katrina and Rita when
the industry faces elevated demand from a solid cold week in both
key consumption regions of the Midwest and Northeast. Today’s
EIA data also serves to put serious doubt in the theory, and one
that we never subscribed to, that demand deterioration as a result
of the storms in the Gulf region , had served to totally mitigate
the resulting lost production. In fact , it is our view, as we
have stated clearly in past interviews, that time will continue
to prove going forward that during periods of peak demand from
weeks of sustained below normal cold, that production lost in the
Gulf has only served to exacerbate an already labored and falling
supply output dilemma , whose solution is far from visible as the
depth and complexity of the possible long-term remedies are yet
to be fully discovered , nor are they even totally understood.
Given this perplexing situation that is painfully and physically
evident from the clearly declining gas yield experienced this past
high consumption summer , which with a traditionally higher rig
count during peak cooling demand, quickly took a hefty year on
year surplus of 260 bcfs and decimated it to almost a 100bcf deficit,
and all before Katrina appeared in the Gulf, will in our opinion
continue to foster dramatic and volatile price swings that push
the upper end of the envelope during periods of peak demand. Having
said that, we feel it is too early to label this market as though
it has already topped out for the season as winter is far from
over , and it is our view that since January , typically the coldest
month is rapidly approaching, that today’s record withdrawal
sets the stage for this market to more likely post another new
record high in the weeks ahead. We also feel that until the degree
to which the January cold deviates from normal is more confidently
forecasted, and thus perceived, prices are likely to be sustained
above the $12 benchmark in our opinion.
Concerning
crude oil , the market found little to get excited about outside
of some rather benign weekly supply numbers from the DOE along
with the typical greed based rhetoric from OPEC in which key
members pronounced little future relief from the consumer choking
and industry taxing elevated petroleum values that the global
economy has been forced to accept under a whole new pricing valuation
that escalated primarily at the onset of the Iraqi war in 2003.
In fact, in quite a contrary display to any proposed relief,
most of the statements by OPEC members, including a declaration
by Kuwait of dependency on foreign oil companies to meet future
proposed necessary output targets, indicated a possible cut in
production in order to circumvent a potential economic slowdown
, possibly leading to a drop in demand in the second quarter.
This of course is all aimed at keeping crude oil prices above
the $50 benchmark, and a far cry from the accepted and well-publicized
desired price range for the basket of crude, declared by OPEC
, not even a year ago, which was way below the current elevated
price. The EIA announced a slight slippage in refinery operating
capacity back to 89.6% as gasoline and distillate fuel production
fell averaging 8.7 million barrels per day and 3.9 million barrels
per day , respectively. Crude oil stocks inched up by a mere
0.9 million barrels from the previous week , ending at 321.2
million barrels and remain well above the upper end of the average
range , while motor gasoline stocks increased by 1.8 million
barrels yet leaving them in the lower half of the average range.
Only distillate fuel inventories inched lower by just 0.1 million
barrels last week , and are now in the middle of the average
range for this time of year. The only element that seem to stand
out as supportive in the weekly update was that both motor gasoline
demand , averaging 9.2 million barrels per day , and distillate
fuel demand , which has averaged over 4.1 million barrels per
day over the same period last year, both reveal elevated demand
over the previous year of 1.1 and 0.9% respectively, and is obviously
, an indirect boost to crude oil values. However , fundamentally,
we continue to feel that due to traditionally high U.S. inventory
levels, and the future implications of Asian demand, crude prices
are still short-term being artificially propped up by winter
demand implications on the products and more critically, Natural
gas. Now let’s take a closer look at the weather
with WS I as any sudden shift in the cold could have a dramatic
impact on the energy mix , and especially natural gas...
WS I Energy Cast 6-10 day Outlook
Winter cold to grip the Eastern two thirds of the country. Below
and much below normal temperatures are forecast over most of the
Eastern two thirds of the country for the balance of the 6 to 10
day period. The cold weather will initially overspread the Midwest,
Plains and Mississippi Valley early next week before shifting to
the East Coast and southeastern US late next week. As a result
, the central US is likely to see the coldest temperatures early
next week , while the East Coast will see their coldest anomalies
late in the week. Either way , daytime highs will struggle to climb
out of the teens and twenties in the Midwest most of next week.
The Northeast will mainly see highs in the twenties and thirties.
The South and Southeast will share in the cold weather as well.
Highs in the forties and fifties will generally prevail over the
southern tier of the country from Texas to Georgia next week. Highs
in the upper thirties are even possible in the coldest locations
on the coldest days for the balance of the six to 10 day period.
Temperature anomalies are expected to average between six and 10?
below normal over most of the Eastern and south-central US. Otherwise
anomalies are forecast to average between 2 and 6? below normal.
In the West medium-range models failed to establish any strong
signals for warm or cold weather. Therefore anomalies are expected
to average close to seasonable levels over most of the western
US for the balance of the six to 10 day period
Conclusion
Natural gas
has clearly embarked on a corrective phase evident from the sharp
retreat , and aggressive selling that was initiated from the
intra-day peak at $15 .78 posted this past Tuesday afternoon.
Since then , what has transpired is a powerful sell-off from
profit-taking and short-term liquidation , resulting in today’s close below
key at support at $14.20, that we feel judging from lost momentum
and other critical technical indicators is not over yet. Looking
ahead and in lieu of the weak short-term technical posture, we
anticipate first a challenge to pivot support at $13 .50 with a
likely follow through to lower intermediate support at $13 .02
and then possibly a deeper probe lower to $12 .80 before scaled-down
buying emerges with enough commitment to shift selling pressure.
With the impact of today’s very bullish fundamental announcement
by the EIA’s storage reduction, we see once again , the potential
convergence of a bullish weather induced fundamental element with
a short-term oversold technical condition, the combination of which
often precedes the most dramatic and volatile price accelerations
in the markets habitual cycle. This scenario , which almost demands
the attention of any cautious trader or market participant, will
obviously be mainly determined by the reality of the immediate
weather ahead. It is our view that the current sharp sell-off in
excess of two dollars from the new historic price peak, set in
the afternoon of December 13th is the market’s desire to
price in this month’s recent frigid cold along with the brief
temperature moderation expected at the end of the month. Yet with
the implications of today’s excessive record storage reduction
and the likelihood that current known weather could further reduce
storage to levels below the five-year average, we see the market
vulnerable to another key bullish reversal igniting a return challenge
to recent highs and a possible new record set in response to the
potential threat of a deeper plunge below normal temperatures approaching
in January. This resumption of the uptrend would be confirmed in
our estimation by a near-term close back above the swing pivot
price of $14 .70 and suggest a return to existing resistance at
$15 .78 for a possible thrust to new highs at $16 .50 longer-term.
This is where the recently updated shut-in gas production, only
improved to 22.28% , declared by the MMS today becomes more influential
on prices and so with the eminent approach of what is typically
the season’s coldest month , along with the expectancy of
larger supply withdrawals, it is our opinion that the unknown factor
prior to the revelation of these events will keep the market suspended
above the $12 benchmark over the short-term. Only a sudden and
dramatic shift in the weather Outlook moderating January’s
threat to more seasonable temperatures could result in a more bearish
scenario signified by a long liquidation and a sharp drop in prices
, revealing a close back down below $12 .25 in our view.
Concerning crude oil, we also see a bearish development in the
chart pattern whereby there exists a pronounced overbought condition
with several technical indicators suggesting weakness ahead as
stochastics, relative strength, momentum, and several oscillators
point to further selling , while the MACD displays a wide negative
divergence along with the parabolic , which is on the cusp of issuing
a sell signal as well. From the technical posture alone , we anticipate
a near-term challenge to pivot support at $58.10 with a potential
for a further decline to $57 .50 especially if heating oil and
natural gas continue to exhibit weakness as they are likely to
complete their corrective patterns in the short-term. The recent
MMS update declaring shut-in oil production at 426,282 BOPD which
is equivalent to 28.42% of the daily oil output in the Gulf of
Mexico will have little influence over the bearish forces that
are currently prevailing over petroleum values in our opinion.
The heavy U.S. supply and a very indirect impact from Winter demand
puts crude oil quite a distance removed from the sensitivity to
cold temperatures experienced by its distant cousin, natural gas.
This clear distinction between the two markets could not have been
made more painfully obvious than in this past weeks price-performance
whereby crude oil, although stubbornly impressive in its own right,
only managed to muster a rally from critical support that we previously
forecasted at $56 .25 to $61 plus, and a far cry from its almost
$71 peak, while natural gas, the Winter headliner, rocketed to
an all-time new high of $15 .78 and eclipsing its previous late
September price peak by almost a dollar! We feel crude values are
more vulnerable during this corrective phase in the heating fuels
to a retest of critical support at $56 .25 before we see another
challenge to the uptrend resistance that would need a close above
$61 .80 in order to set the stage for a continuation of the bull
trend and a test of the breakout price at $62.50.
FUTURES AND OPTIONS TRADING INVOLVE RISK OF LOSS AND MAY NOT BE SUITABLE FOR EVERYONE.
Decemeber 15,
2005
United Strategic Investors Group
Guy Gleichmann, President
1926 Hollywood Blvd Suite 311
Hollywood, Florida 33020
(800) 974 – 8744
www.strategicinvestors.us