Consensus Report:
August 24, 2006
Natual Gas and Oil Report
Crude
Holds Support after Gasoline Collapse, while Natural Gas
Rebounds on Storm Hype.
Technical Outlook: In
our last report dated August 10 we said natural gas was more
definitively bearish and that we expected prices to fall back
through support at $6.80 especially if the resistance level at
$7.60 was not reached soon. This not only transpired, but prices
fell down through our target at $6.80 all the way to $6.45 before
staging a sharp recovery. Looking ahead, especially after today's
rather abrupt reversal to the upside of $.20 and rebound above
the $7.0 benchmark, the momentum suggests a strong challenge
to key previous resistance at the $7.60 level near term. However,
the ongoing pattern has bearish overtones and suggests the market
is vulnerable to another sharp rejection from the band of resistance
above starting at $7.40 scaled up to $7.65 that could easily
send prices cascading lower back to test intermediate support
at $6.80 and if breached a further washout down through existing
critical support at $6.45 could easily materialize. Only a strong
close above resistance at $7.60, due to short covering, would
indicate a continuation of the short term uptrend and set the
stage for another challenge to pivot resistance at $7.80. We
also warn against putting too much reliance upon technical indicators
right now when the market in our opinion is almost totally dependent
upon weather and its fundamental threat impact on production
in the Gulf which we will discuss in the next section.
Fundamental Supply Update
Today the EIA reported
an expected net injection of 57 bcfs that was right in line with
previous estimates that varied only by a few bcfs from all three
key surveys of Bloomberg, Dow Jones, and the ICAP estimates.
The market was already poised to rally as prices were up about
$.17 before the DOE release on storm hype and concern over tropical
storm Debby and more specifically tropical depression number
five which is slated to become possibly storm Ernesto later next
week. With storage currently at 2857 bcfs which is still 291
higher than last year at this time and 339 or 13.5% above the
five-year average of 2518 bcfs, the market is hardly short on
supply. However as always with natural gas the market is never
short of the ability to exaggerate and so literally before there
has been any credible weather reports indicating a storm pattern
or even a level of development that suggests a direct threat
to the Texas and Louisiana production areas within the Gulf,
the short covering has begun with traders prematurely driving
up prices as if a Gulf hurricane has already been predestined.
Meanwhile in reality tropical storm Debby has already been forecast
by most credible and known weather forecasters to become a threat
only to marine shipping as its current path leads it northward
into the Atlantic Ocean with no apparent threat to any land mass,
while tropical depression number five has some strong challenges
ahead such as a low-pressure system moving southward down from
the Bahamas that is on a collision path and is expected through
wind shear to seriously weaken further development to this storm.
It has been further explained to me from WSI weather that under
the current pattern if it should develop further into a tropical
storm it will more likely move westward into the Yucatán
area and or impact the southern Mexican coast or Bay of Campeche
area rather than the northern area of the Gulf of Mexico which
would steer it far from affecting any critical energy production
areas off the coast of Texas and Louisiana. This leaves the market
after its recent rally well above the $7.0 benchmark quite vulnerable
to a storm disappointing collapse whereby hurricane hype buyers
will soon abandon their positions with haste likely to cause a
vigorous long liquidation and resulting in prices declining to
new lows quickly. Looking ahead to the upcoming moderation in temperatures
especially in the Upper Midwest and Northeast, leaves little natural
gas demand for cooling needs, should a production threatening storm
not materialize.
Concerning crude oil this week's EIA
update Wednesday gave little support to the recent retreat in
petroleum prices led by the gasoline collapse that started last
week as yesterday's surprising increase of 0.4 million barrels
of unleaded only further served to confirm. Little support came
from the drop of 0.6 million barrels to crude stocks as it's
still left 330.4 million barrels and well above the upper end
of the average range for this time of year. Refinery's also operated
at a robust 92.8% of capacity last week while gasoline production
increased slightly over the previous week averaging nearly 9.3
million barrels per day. While gasoline demand implications remained
firm at 9.6 million barrels per day or 1.7% above the same period
last year, it failed to prevent the collapse of almost $.50 from
high to low in the price of gasoline over the past 16 sessions
basis spot September unleaded, as traders obviously feel peak
driving season and thus demand is behind us. This only seemed
to further complement the recent cease-fire to the war between
Israel and the Hezbollah that finally put an end to the senseless
atrocities and merciless killing of the Lebanese people caught
in the middle of the conflict and unfortunately most of which were
children. Although this provided no immediate relief to supply
tightness as this particular conflict had never posed any direct
threat to oil supplies in the first-place, it's still seemed to
alleviate some of the of the tension between key sympathizers,
that if the violence had continued and then spread to these supporters, then
in directly oil supplies could have been compromised. It is just
like the ongoing dilemma between Iran's insistence on furthering
its nuclear ambitions through continuous uranium enrichment and
the opposition from the UN Security Council and mainly the United
States who believe their nuclear agenda threatens to further destabilize
the already precarious security of the region. And while the strong
threats of economic sanctions up to now have failed to interrupt
the flow of even one barrel of crude oil, the potential military
confrontation that could erupt from the disagreement between the
two countries has been responsible for an estimated $10-$15 fear
premium added on to the price of crude oil. While Teheran gave
no indication of stopping their uranium enrichment program prior
to while offering to continue to negotiate the incentive package
proposed by the UN Security Council, which quickly drew the criticism
of President Bush, some diplomats close to the situation believe
Iran hinted it may consider halting enrichment during the negotiations
should talks continue. And so the Iran nuclear Saga continues,
holding crude prices hostage along with it as the confrontation
unfolds and rightfully so as the second-largest producer in OPEC
remains in jeopardy to a possible future military conflict with
the US. Prices did find some support today from a production snag
reported from Prudhoe Bay Alaska whereby a compressor problem in
the western half of the field has reduced output by 90,000 barrels
per day limiting production to 110,000 barrels. Crude prices no
doubt found further minor support today from the recent injection
of storm activity in the southern Caribbean between tropical storm
Debby and a couple tropical waves that are moving westward from
the African coast and now threaten Jamaica in the Atlantic Basin.
And with last year's record hurricane count and the resulting devastation
from the "perfect 2 storm punch" delivered as a direct hit to critical
oil infrastructure in the Gulf of Mexico by hurricanes Katrina
and Rita, it seems traders are short covering and buying out of
fear even before receiving forecast confirmation of the storm's
threatening path. This overcompensation and enhanced speculative
buying only serves to artificially inject volatility into an already
overheated and inflated energy complex. Let's not take a closer
look at the weather and its implications over the energy market
in the near term...
WSI Weather Forecast 6-10 day Outlook
Seasonable to seasonably warm temperatures are expected to encompass most of the country next week. As a result, near and above normal temperatures are forecast over most of the continental U.S. for the balance of the next week and 6-10 day forecast periods. The exception occurs in the Pacific Northwest, where seasonably cool temperatures are forecast during the 6- 10 day period in response to a developing West Coast trough. By mid-to-late week, daytime high temperatures are only expected to climb into the 60s and 70s in Seattle and Portland. Meanwhile, the most persistent warmth is anticipated over the South-Central and Southeastern U.S. next week. Highs in the Southeast are generally expected to climb into the 80s and low 90s most of next week while Texas and the South-Central U.S. will continue to see highs rise well into the 90s. The warmest temperatures in the Midwest and North-Central are forecast to arrive during the latter half of next week, when a building central ridge will bring widespread highs in the 80s to near 90 degrees. The Northeast may experience a brief period of warm weather early next week; however a building ridge over Greenland (negative NAO) will bring persistent troughing and seasonable to seasonably cool readings late next week and next week High in the Northeast during the latter half of next week are not expected to climb into the 70s and 80s. Finally, seasonable to seasonably warm temperatures are forecast over California and the southwestern U.S. for the balance of the next week and 6-10 day period. Highs over California are generally expected to rise into the 80s and 90s most of next week while maxes in the 90s and low 100s are forecast to continue in the Southwest. The other area of concern late next week surrounds a potential a tropical system in the Gulf of Mexico. Our current WSI tropical forecast favors the current wave east of the Windward Islands strengthening into a tropical storm or a weak hurricane over the next 5-6 days. This system is forecast to emerge in the Gulf of Mexico near the Yucatan Channel or Yucatan Channel near the middle of next week. As it does, the system will begin to become influenced by the persistent sub-tropical ridge along the Gulf Coast. This sub-tropical ridge will attempt to steer the system into the western Gulf, reducing the threat for the landfall along the Upper Gulf Coast. If the system does strength more than currently expected, it could threaten the central Gulf Coast, but that is the lower probability at this time. The system has appreciable obstacles to overcome the next 5-6 days, but it may threaten the Gulf of Mexico next week. The probability of this threat is about 40% at this time.
Conclusion
Natural gas took out all of our targets
from our last report dated August 10 when we forecast a price
collapse that would follow rejection from the resistance band
between $7.40 and $7.65 that we said would precede a decline
back through support at $6.80. Prices not only took out the $6.80
support but then continued to fall to $6.45 before staging the
key reversal. Price action over this past week we feel, although
reaching grossly oversold levels technically, has now been dominated
by the fundamentals of weather which makes price forecasting
more difficult as the market's direction is almost totally determined
by the storm's path. We feel from the current WS I weather forecast
which states the current tropical depression slated to possibly
become tropical storm Ernesto and even a weak hurricane has serious
obstacles to overcome before it can even threaten the Gulf of
Mexico after which if it does is only expected to affect the
western Gulf near the Yucatán Channel which
puts its threat potential to actual oil and gas infrastructure
as a very low probability. Under this scenario in our opinion natural
gas prices are already over-inflated in proportion to existing
record supplies and once again will do little to prevent starting
in November with between 3400 and 3500 bcfs for winter supply.
Only an unexpected sudden change of course to the tropical storm
leading it to a collision course with the production areas of the
Upper Gulf Coast, do we then expect a continuation of the short
term up trend to challenge $7.80 and then the $8.0 benchmark once
again. However if the current WS I forecast transpires whereby
Ernesto either fails to reach hurricane status or even after reaching
a category one level then moves westward into the Mexican Coast
thereby bypassing the production areas of the Upper Gulf we anticipate
a noticeable price collapse that could rapidly bring a return to
$6.45 and below for a possible challenge to $6.10 and further as
the heat factor in the Upper Midwest and Northeast moderates as
summer winds down.
With regards to
crude oil in the petroleum complex, we see the market in a major
tug-of-war between the negativity of the declining unleaded gasoline
market that is now plagued by both weak fundamentals involving
diminishing summer driving demand and a technical breakdown as
key support was recently broken at $1.88 per gallon basis spot,
and then the opposing bullish forces of overseas tension mainly
in the situation in Iran, robust demand from Asia, and further
reduced output in Iraq keeping the supply demand balance tight
overall. We believe the fact existing excess capacity within
OPEC still remains at approximately 1.5 million barrels per day
and mainly to be supplied by Saudi Arabia, keeps the oil market
with that one foot on the proverbial "banana
peel", whereby the world is still only one hurricane, one terrorist
act, or one war or military engagement, or even one major labor
strike away from causing a major imbalance to the supply demand
exchange and suddenly the world's daily output is not keeping up
with consumption. This ongoing dilemma continues to keep the market
on edge with new highs above the $78 per barrel benchmark only
a few trading sessions away in the minds of traders unless something
more significant takes place such as a peaceful settlement to Iran's
nuclear challenge. Now if that were to transpire near-term especially
after the recent cease-fire, despite the fact that many feel the
situation between Israel and the Hezbollah is still potentially
explosive, we could see oil prices finally break key support at
$68.10 which has been maintained for almost four months, and then
fall much farther down to possibly test $62.50, but that is based
on the Iran challenge being worked out even temporarily, which
at this point seems optimistic. It still seems to be with the ongoing
Iran nuclear challenge looming, continued reduced output from militant
activity in Nigeria, renewed threats from Al Qaeda to Western interests
in retaliation for our support of Israel and our failing campaign
in Iraq, and the implications of peak storm season ahead in the
US, the deck is still stacked in favor of the Bulls and thus keeping
the long-term up trend in petroleum intact whereby it will take
something significant to break support at $68 on close. You saw
how briefly the market spent testing support at $70 basis spot
recently whereby after only one day prices have already recovered
back to threaten $72.50 basis spot currently.
FUTURES AND OPTIONS TRADING INVOLVE RISK OF LOSS AND MAY NOT BE SUITABLE FOR EVERYONE.
Agugust 24,
2006
United Strategic Investors Group
Guy Gleichmann, President
1926 Hollywood Blvd Suite 311
Hollywood, Florida 33020
(800)
974 – 8744